Skip to content

“Follow your Passion!” Good or Bad advice?

100,000s of Americans who have lost their jobs or are currently underemployed are giving up on searching for jobs in their same old field and pursuing opportunities to turn their passion into a paycheck. They are embracing the familiar advice to just “Follow your Passion!” We love this advice because it is both daring and altruistic. It reminds me of the VonTrapps, in their matching lederhosen, hiking over the Alps to their new freedom with a bevy of nuns gloriously singing, "Climb Every Mountain." As Cal Newport says, it is “A big, bold move that changes everything: this is a powerful storyline.” But is it good advice?

“Here’s the key: there is no special passion waiting for you to discover. Passion is something that is cultivated. It can be cultivated in many, many different fields. Therefore, it doesn’t make sense to say, ‘I don’t know what my passion is.’ What does make sense is to say, ‘I haven’t yet cultivated a passion.’”

“Finding work you love is not about following your passion but getting good at something rare and valuable”

-- Cal Newport is an assistant professor at MIT, computer scientist and author of, “So Good They Can’t Ignore You” From an interview with the Minimalists (www.minimalists.com)

Where "Follow your Passion" falls short:

  • Most people are not walking around with a clear understanding of what their passion is
  • There is no evidence that if someone finds a job doing that one great thing, they will enjoy it.
  • As a friend of mine told me, "It's not doing what you are passionate about; it's being passionate about what you are doing."
  • Cal Newports says that Passion is the result of putting in the hours to hone your craft. He calls it building your "Career Capital."

  • My husband always says, “to be good at what you love, do it 1000 times and then do it again until it becomes effortless.” You cannot rely on your love for what you do, you have to be good at it.
  • Malcolm Gladwell, in his book Outliers, says, “researchers have settled on what they believe is the magic number for true expertise: 10,000 hours.”
  • Steve Martin, quoted in Newport’s book, says, “they want to hear ‘this is how you get an agent’ but I always say ‘be so good they can’t ignore you.’”
  • Newport suggests we change our mindset: Cultivate a “Craftsman Mindset” that focuses on what value you are offering the world and avoid a “Passion Mindset” that focuses on what the value of your job is offering you
  • ACTION STEPS YOU CAN TAKE:

    Read more in Cal Newport's fascinating book, "So Good They Can't Ignore You."

    Need help identifying different fields and careers where you can apply your passions? Schedule a Career Coaching appointment to implement a Career Assessment and begin discovering ways to cultivate your passions.

    Check out the many resources we have for career exploration.


    Amazon Says: In this eye-opening account, Cal Newport debunks the long-held belief that "follow your passion" is good advice.  Not only is the cliché flawed-preexisting passions are rare more...
    Amazon Says: In this eye-opening account, Cal Newport debunks the long-held belief that "follow your passion" is good advice.  Not only is the cliché flawed-preexisting passions are rare and have little to do with how most people end up loving their work-but it can also be dangerous, leading to anxiety and chronic job hopping. After making his case against passion, Newport sets out on a quest to discover the reality of how people end up loving what they do. Spending time with organic farmers, venture capitalists, screenwriters, freelance computer programmers, and others who admitted to deriving great satisfaction from their work, Newport uncovers the strategies they used and the pitfalls they avoided in developing their compelling careers. Matching your job to a preexisting passion does not matter, he reveals. Passion comes after you put in the hard work to become excellent at something valuable, not before. In other words, what you do for a living is much less important than how you do it. With a title taken from the comedian Steve Martin, who once said his advice for aspiring entertainers was to "be so good they can't ignore you," Cal Newport's clearly written manifesto is mandatory reading for anyone fretting about what to do with their life, or frustrated by their current job situation and eager to find a fresh new way to take control of their livelihood. He provides an evidence-based blueprint for creating work you love. SO GOOD THEY CAN'T IGNORE YOU will change the way we think about our careers, happiness, and the crafting of a remarkable life. less...
    Amazon

    Amazon Says: What is the lifelong potential of the human mind?  Might I have talents or brainpower that I'm unaware of? Can I make money and a difference doing s more...
    Amazon Says: What is the lifelong potential of the human mind?  Might I have talents or brainpower that I'm unaware of? Can I make money and a difference doing something I love? Is there some science to this or just luck? Millions of us in our 40's, 50's and 60's face career, financial and personal challenges beyond anything we anticipated--we're filled with fresh uncertainties. We've seen careers derailed and investments devastated by economic chaos. Some of us have grown restless or burned out in our businesses or professions. Others have unexpectedly 'flunked retirement,' finding the so-called 'golden years' mind-numbingly boring. However we've come to it, the challenge is the same:  What Now? Personally driven by this question, Peabody award-winning journalist and Fortune 100 leadership consultant Mark S. Walton set out on his most fascinating assignment yet. Crisscrossing America to meet with remarkably re-inventive people, and researching the latest breakthroughs in brain science, psychology, creativity and happiness, he made three life-altering discoveries: State-of-the-art neuroscience has revealed that we are hard-wired for reinvention through the emergence of extraordinary new brainpowers in life's second half. A growing number of men and women are learning to leverage this inborn potential. In midlife, they're raising the bar--inventing profitable new careers, businesses, and avenues for social impact that extend well into their 70's, 80's, even 90's.  Longevity experts are increasingly convinced that doing work that 'pays it forward' to future generations pays us back in personal long-term health and happiness. What unrealized possibilities exist for each of us in midlife and beyond?  How do we find and unlock our unique talents and capabilities?  What kinds of people have accomplished this? What can we learn from their experiences? In Boundless Potential Walton shares his surprising and encouraging findings, weaving first-hand accounts, cutting edge research, and practical lessons into an actionable blueprint for redesigning our lives and work. Entertaining, informative, and empowering, this groundbreaking book delivers overwhelming evidence that we were never meant to downgrade our ambitions or goals, but to continually reinvent them.    less...
    Amazon
    Print

    Comment about this page...